Home  
Upcoming Conferences  
2012/05 The 14th Annual Sedona ConferenceŽ on Complex Litigation - Class Actions
2012/10 The 13th Annual Sedona ConferenceŽ on Patent Litigation
2012/10 Antitrust Law & Litigation IX
To Register  
Past Conferences  
2012/10 Antitrust Law & Litigation IX
2012/10 The 13th Annual Sedona ConferenceŽ on Patent Litigation
2012/05 The 14th Annual Sedona ConferenceŽ on Complex Litigation - Class Actions
2011/10 Antitrust Law & Litigation XIII: International Enforcement & Its Political Underpinnings
2011/10 Patent Litigation XII
2011/04 Complex Litigation XIII: The Future of Civil Litigation 2
2010/10 Antitrust Law & Litigation XII
2010/10 Patent Litigation XI
2010/04 Complex Litigation XII - The Future of Civil Litigation: Legislative and Behavioral Changes
2010/01 EDiscovery Dispute Resolution Program For
Special Masters & Mediators
2009/10 Antitrust Law & Litigation XI
2009/10 Patent Litigation X
2009/04 Complex Litigation XI: The Attorney-Client Privilege: Rule 502, Selective Waiver, Privilege Logs & Related Issues.
2008/10 Patent Litigation IX
2008/09 Antitrust Law & Litigation X: The Globalisation of Antitrust Enforcement
2008/04 Complex Litigation X - Health Law & Medical Products Litigation: Common Ground
2007/10 Antitrust Law & Litigation IX
2007/10 Patent Litigation VIII
2007/04 Complex Litigation IX: The Attorney-Client Privilege
2006/10 Antitrust Law & Litigation
2006/10 Patent Litigation
2006/05 Mass Torts
2005/11 Antitrust Law & Litigation
2005/10 Patent Litigation
2005/04 Litigating Mass Torts
2004/11 Antitrust Law & Litigation VI
2004/10 Patent Litigation V
2004/03 Complex Litigation VI
2003/11 Antitrust Law & Litigation
2003/11 Patent Litigation
2003/05 Digital Privacy And Security
2003/04 Complex Litigation V
2002/11 Antitrust Law & Litigation
2002/11 Patent Litigation
2002/05 Health Law & Litigation
2002/05 Complex Litigation
2001/11 Patent Litigation
2001/11 Antitrust Law & Litigation
2001/05 The Internet: Privacy, Property & Regulation
2001/04 Complex Litigation
2000/11 Patent Litigation
2000/11 Antitrust: Law & Litigation
Raves  
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
About Us  
Mission
FAQ
Advisory Board
Executive Director
Contact Us
Sponsors  
Working Group Series  
Information
Application
WGS Audio Update Series  
TSC Institute  
RFP+/eDiscovery Vendors  
Mission
Vendor Panel
Open Invitation
Speaker's Bureau  
The Journal  
Publications  
Past Newsletters  
Spring 2008 Newsletter
Fall_2007_Newsletter
Newsletter 2007 Winter
Newsletter 2006 Summer
Newsletter 2006 Winter
Newsletter 2005 Fall
Newsletter 2005 January
Newsletter 2005 Winter
Newsletter 2004 Fall
Newsletter 2004 Summer
Photos  
AT08 in Florence, Italy
Sedona Photos
Conference Photos
Data Deluge Summit
Contact Us  

    
Zubulake Revisited? Dissecting the Pension Committee v. Banc of America Opinion

February 10, 2010     01:00pm - 02:15pm Eastern


Agenda


Panelists


The first major judicial opinion on e-discovery for 2010 was delivered by a judge who was already a distinguished jurist in the field and it harkened back to a landmark decision from the past. The January 15 Amended Opinion and Order in Pension Committee of the University of Montreal Pension Plan, et al. v. Banc of America Securities, LLC, et al. was titled "Zubulake Revisited: Six Years Later" by its author, Hon. Shira A. Scheindlin of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, who stated, "Once again, I have been compelled to closely review the discovery efforts of parties in a litigation, and once again have found that these efforts were flawed. As famously noted, '[t]hose who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.'"

Pension Committee details the data preservation efforts of 13 plaintiff investors who joined an action to recover an alleged half-billion dollars in losses from the liquidation of two British Virgin Islands-based hedge funds. More to the point, the opinion details the lack of preservation efforts by the plaintiffs, finding that seven of the plaintiffs acted negligently and six of the plaintiffs acted with gross negligence, resulting in the probable loss or destruction of relevant data, and requiring further discovery, monetary sanctions, and a carefully-crafted spoliation instruction to the jury. In her lengthy opinion, Judge Scheindlin discusses the duty of preservation and what it requires of parties, distinguishes between the various levels of culpability in the plaintiffs' conduct, explores the shifting burdens of proof in spoliation claims, and sets out the appropriate remedies for the failure to preserve electronically stored information in litigation.

In this webinar, our distinguished panel will take a careful look at the Pension Committee opinion and what it teaches all of us - plaintiffs, defendants, and the Judiciary - about the duty of preservation and the sanctions for spoliation. Joining the panel will be Hon. Elizabeth Laporte, United States Magistrate Judge in the Northern District of California, attorneys Jonathan Redgrave of Nixon Peabody LLP and Jennifer Young of Milberg LLP, and veteran e-discovery technical expert John Jessen of Datacon/Electronic Evidence Discovery. We are extending our usual one hour panel discussion to 75 minutes to accommodate more of your questions.

Pricing:

$79 Working Group Members of The Sedona Conference®

$99 General Public


Watch This Seminar Now!

CDs:
To purchase a CD of this program, please call 1-800-701-5161. Discounts
apply for program registrants.

Agenda   
Wednesday, Feb 10
Time              Session Panelists
01:00-02:00   Presentation
-Culpability: Defining Negligence, Gross Negligence, and Willfulness in the Discovery Context
-The Duty to Preserve and Spoliation
-Relevance and Prejudice: Burdens of Proof
-Appropriate Remedies, Including the "Spoliation Instruction"
   
02:00-02:15   Questions and Answer Session    
 

Panelists   
Chair
Kenneth J. Withers
The Sedona Conference®, Phoenix, AZ
 
Faculty
John H. Jessen
Jessen and Associates, Inc., Hunts Point, WA
Hon. Elizabeth D. Laporte
U.S. District Court for the District of California, San Francisco, CA
Jonathan M. Redgrave
Redgrave LLP, Washington, D.C.
Jennifer L. Young
Milberg LLP, New York, NY